Aspin, a couple things here , I would use a 1/2 round double cut smooth, not too coarse to catch the soft silver. After the general shape is cut out you can lay the "moon" flat with the curve facing the bench pins cut out or the edge of the bench.The file can be worked up & down sorta like a brooch, you can watch the angle of the cut and the pressure you use. Smooth the back of the moon with a flat file & run the 1/2 round edge perpedicular to the piece & side to side like draw filing. This should cut down on the dips & swales.
Mtlctr